The most widely used type of roofing in the US is asphalt shingles. Take a look around any neighborhood and you’ll find the alternative, metal is much less common. However, this does not mean traditional shingles are the superior product. In fact, in the past couple of decades metal roofing has soon major improvements. Both types of roofs have advantages and disadvantages. When building a new house or replacing your existing roof, it really comes down to which works best for you.
Many people do not realize this, but they should replace their roof about every 20 years or so. It’s a large expense, but developing leaks and other problems will end up costing even more in the long run. When it is time to replace your roof, you’ve got a tough decision to make. A variety of factors will come into play as you decide which type of roof you should installed. The climate, way you live, the look your after, and cost are all going to come into play.
The decision is a tough one, and we want to help. Ahead you’ll find a quick comparison between metal and traditional shingle roofs. Ultimately deciding between the two is a choice you’ll have to make, but hopefully this will help!
Roofing Cost
Metal Roofing
Metal roofs are expensive, it is a fact that we cannot avoid. The cost will change depending on the exact material you select. For example, steel or aluminum is on the less expensive end of the spectrum, while copper or zinc roofing is much more expensive. Installation is also usually more complex for metal roofs, so that adds to the cost as well.
Traditional Roofing
Prices for traditional roofing materials vary as well, but not as significantly as do metal materials. The shingles themselves are less than metal materials, but you also have to include underlayment and felt in costs. Even still, they do not equal the cost of a metal roof. And you can still get a great roof with asphalt shingles. Many people even like the aesthetic of these roofs better. When cost is a major concern, it is probably the best option.
Roof Longevity/Durability
Metal Roofing
Longevity and durability is a major advantage for metal roofs. In the past, they actually had problems, often needing to be replaced after 10 years or less. Rusting was a serious issue at the time. However, improvements have been made with alloys that are resistant to rust. Additionally, new paints have been developed that protect the metal roofs – even from salt water and intense weather conditions. You’ll often find metal roofing backed by warranties of 50 years or more.
Traditional Roofing
Though they don’t last as long as metal roofs, traditional shingled roofs aren’t terrible when it comes to durability. You’ll usually find asphalt roofs with warranties lasting as long as 20 or 25 years. A major issue with this type of roofing though, can be the weather. Unlike metal roofs, which hold up well in a variety of conditions, hail and ice can severely damage a traditionally shingled roof. The repairs can be costly and if the damage is bad enough, a new roof might be necessary.
Roof Heating and Cooling Efficiency
Metal Roofing
As odd as it may seem, metal roofs are great at keeping houses cool. If you live in a hot, sunny environment, a metal roof might be a great choice. These roofs can actually reduce your cooling costs significantly. Rather than absorbing sunlight, metal reflects it. These reduces the heat inside the home. For cold climates, metal roofs have a tougher time keeping things warm. However, if insulation is placed correctly, it isn’t an issue.
Traditional Roofing
Asphalt roof shingles absorb sunlight, making it harder to cool the house in warmer months. Still, if insulation is sufficient, cooling costs shouldn’t be too outrageous. And in the winter, asphalt roofing keeps warmth in quite well. However, issues still come up when heavy, wet snow lays on the roof.
Roof Soundproofing
Metal Roofing
Soundproofing is one issue that metal roofs face. Even with sufficient insulation, a metal roof can be louder than their asphalt counterparts. For this reason, some people choose to put metal roofs over the top of asphalt shingles. However, this is extremely expensive, and roofing codes don’t allow it all areas. The additional noise during rain storms is something you may have to learn to put up with if you want the durability and quality of a metal roof. All in all, metal roofs aren’t as loud as you probably imagine. A roof with insulation is nowhere near as loud as a tin roof with no padding.
Traditional Roofing
Asphalt does a great job absorbing sound, especially from rain and hail. You can rest assured knowing that sound issues probably won’t be a problem with your traditional roofing materials.
Conclusion
As you can see, there are several key differences between metal and asphalt roofs. The decision must be made while considering a variety of factors. Take your time, and talk to an expert before choosing.
Contact the Littleton roof replacement pros National Home Improvement for a free estimate in the Littleton area. We offer both traditional and metals roofs!
